In Part II, we examine the soul of this team under this coach, relive the wild-card disaster and try to figure out where the Green Bay Packers go next. The heat is on for Matt LaFleur to win.
Interesting read. One thing you have done, Ty, is undone the perception that MLF doesn't hold his coaches accountable, which has been something other writers were putting out there.
Yes, he is a wound-tight perfectionist, and that was known when he came from the Titans years ago. They also needed a guy who could get them from Rodgers to Love successfully; again, it worked.
I think there has been, even going back to MM, a disconnect in the players MLF needs and the ones Gute brings in...if guys don't like getting chewed out when they screw up and being held accountable, then I am sorry thats not on MLF.
Gute's buying the groceries... MLF cooking. If the guy buying those groceries isn't getting the correct ingredients, don't blame the cook when it tastes bad. Dig deeper on Gute Ty.
There’s nothing in these articles that make me think Matt LaFleur is a bad coach, much less the reason the Packers have struggled. He’s highly intelligent, detail-oreinted, chasing perfection, holds his players, staff, and himself accountable. That’s what people expect from an NFL head coach. Dunn keeps trying to draw parallels between LaFleur and McDermott, but the only thing I see is that they’ve had a few awkward moments in front of the team and Matt has reportedly really grown here. Really this article sounds like it’s the players’ messing it up, especially looking at what Dunn writes about the Bears layoffs loss. I gotta say, I see a demanding, hard-working, earnest head coach that really wants to win and is willing to endure the painful parts of growth to get there.
Matt received the worst grades from players in 8 years. The team was 9-3-1 and SB contenders when that happened. Reading the articles only reinforced of what I knew about his dealings with players. Makes me wonder why we still have coaches who should have been fired a year, two years too long. No one wants to come here to work with Matt in that type of culture. Jeff Hafley is that dude and punked Matt on the way out. Basaccia just left but did so very late in the process and probably out of spite.
I fully believe he did something to Ben Johnson or someone close to Ben Johnson because there was no reason for him to target Matt like that from the jump. 😂😂 they are coming to Lambeau next weekend to cost Matt his job and Matt better be prepared for it. After seeing how we looked against Atlanta, I don’t give us a shot against the Bears no matter who the Qb is.
I think we care too much what players think. We watched the players for Vegas try to pick their HC two years in a row and those years ended horribly.
Maybe the coaches aren’t fired when the fanbase thinks they should be because the org knows it’s a players problem and not coaching. They’re eventually fired because we have the players we have, and we gotta try something new.
Maybe it's a player problem because he doesn't develop players well. Most of the players that have left here have improved, while most of the non "star" players brought in have declined. That means something
It’s Dunne. MLF would have ripped you for the error. :).
But, all teasing aside, the open question for me is how he starts to empower his team without those old vets. Love doesn’t seem to be Rodgers, or Favre, in those contexts. Who is the next Butler, or Lang — the leader who rises to bring the fight they seem to lack. MLF can handle X’s and O’s — but can he find the right places and people to influence momentum when it’s sorely needed. That’s the question.
It’s a good question, but isn’t that up to the players and who the front office brings in? Mike McCarthy didn’t make TJ Lang into leader, Lang did that himself with his actions.
I’ll be interested to see if part 3 points the pen at Gutekunst. He turned this team into the youngest in the nfl for three straight years with very little vet presence and leadership. It’s been fascinating to hear Kevin Zeitler talk this week about how eager the young OLine is to learn from him
If the past foretells the future, Mr. Dunne has many parts left in this series, however the season goes :-). I’m sure the GM is going to get his share. The Packers always had a tough road for this season. It doesn’t get easier. Rebounding from 3-6 or something of the like will take a very crispy, well-polished effort of increased aggression and execution.
Agreed. LaFleur isn't perfect, but he's not a bad coach. The collapse last year was frustrating and concerning, but it was also abnormal for any NFL team. The perception by some fans that it has been a regular hallmark of his entire career is absurd.
Today against Tampa Bay, for example, he's put together a good offensive game plan. Really this is what have wanted to see from him early this year, the creativity that helped Malik Willis play so well last year (and that he hasn't gotten nearly enough credit for). He also resurrected Aaron Rodgers' career-people forget, Rodgers wasn't playing that great in McCarthy's final few years. If he's such a poor coach, Rodgers would've kept sliding downhill and LaFleur probably never makes it long enough to have Willis be a cheap backup who eventually cashed in.
It's not LaFleur's fault receivers are dropping passes today. It's not his fault the GM has neglected the offensive and defensive lines and given him sub-par cornerbacks (one a high draft pick rookie being thrown into the fire as instantly the team's best CB; the other-Nixon-who is proving he should not be an NFL starter). It's not his fault that a number of his better players are injured. Think the talent on this team is being exaggerated; this roster has some massive holes, and a number of its most talented players are injured or in the case of Love and his OL have not been protected well by the GM. Blaming all that on the coach just doesn't compute.
Adam G. : It IS LeFleur’s fault that receivers are dropping passes, It is LeFleur’s fault that the offensive line doesn’t have depth. Matt LeFleur is the head coach, responsible for the play on the field and selecting the back ups who may be on the field. To suggest otherwise absolves LeFleur of every error his team makes on the field.
Great articles capturing exactly what myself and a lot of other GB fans think about LaFleur. He's an excellent offensive mind, that much has always been clear. But he's unable to cope with adversity as a coach and when things start going the wrong direction, he melts down. There are precious few games, either with or without Rodgers, where the Packers have been able to right the ship midway though under LaFleur.
He may not be the sole problem, but he's not done much to convince me he has a solution.
Felt strongly after last season that LaFleur needed to go. Still feel that way. Wasn’t sure about Gutey. Now think he needs to go too. Utter disaster with oline and not enough emphasis on smarts.
In Part Two of this LeFleur series, the Getty image of LeFleur on the sideline shows the deep haunt of fear in his eyes. LeFleur is completely afraid to fail and because he can’t control his fear, his fear of mistakes seeps into the minds of his players. He is psychologically unfit to be the head coach of Green Bay’s football team. Players put up with Lombardi’s obsession with detail because they knew he would take them where they wanted to go, and Lombardi would show his players NFL championship money, $25,000 a year by the mid-60s, which was sometimes higher than the salaries most players were making. LeFleur has won nothing, and won’t win a Super Bowl in Green Bay. LeFleur’s players know it.
I would really like to stop reminding you that Jordan Love is not one of “the best in the game” as you again said in Part One, paraphrasing on my part. He isn’t. He’s plateaued into an average quarterback, just as his high school coach warned he would become if he continued to throw off his back foot. Of the four quarterbacks in the NFC North, Love is third. If Kyle Murray continues to improve in Minnesota’s offense, Love could be last in the division by season’s end.
Other than that, Tyler, this is excellent reporting and writing. I thank you for your dogged investigation of what’s going on inside of 1265 Lombardi Ave. GoLongTD is worth every dollar, every year.
After reading the series I‘m stuck with 2 impressions:
1. incredibly illuminating and informative - and now I, who have been strongly in the fire MLF camp, am a bit less convinced about what to do. The problems are nuanced and complicated, there is no easy fix. If they had hired Harbaugh, the obvious choice, would everything be better?
2. in my opinion, the watershed moment with this organisation is and always will be the Seattle Championship Game. Something broke that day. Rodgers was never the same after that. He became much more of a Me First guy. The fans lost something that day as well. I myself expect the worst to happen more often than not. The whole aura around the Packers got destroyed. In Love‘s first season it seemed a corner was there for the taking. The W in Dallas was magic. But then the SF game….
So where does that leave everything? I think it is a culture thing and it transcends Head Coaches or QBs or GMs or Presidents. I would have loved to see a coach like Vrabel hired. But in addition, a GM with another philosophy is necessary.
E.g. I think Bob is onto something with his Wonderlic mantra.
Ty had to work hard for this article. It wasn't just laying down quotes. It was thinking, analysing, interpreting and studying the quotes and using them to support his points. This was like running the ball all day long and gaining 3 yards every carry. Damn good work.
I hope you will still cover his asinine stubbornness in regards to his coaches. He seems so blinded by loyalty that he refuses to fire failing coaches until it is several years too late. Look at Butkus, this line has regressed massively since he took the job, and Barry, sweet fancy moses he was in over his head, and Bisaccia. It is never ending....
a couple of things. 1) MLF is great at the x and o’s. The man cannot make adjustments during a game That’s a huge part of understanding the X’s and O’s. Clock management, isn’t that part of handling the X’s and O’s? Putting up with a special teams that rates near the bottom until last year when they moved up to 15th? How does poor field position equate into understanding X’s and O’s? Telling everyone from day 1, that he wants to establish the run game first without doing anything to move the needle. Being last in 3rd down conversions…..I think part of the issue is local sportswriters are afraid to call a spade a spade because if they do they’ll lose opportunities for accessing players and coaches. This market is soo small that a sports writer/announcer can’t be honest.
2). There is a disconnect between what players Gutey brings in and what MLF gets. MLF says he needs to establish the run but lo and behold every o- line MLF has had has rated poorly in run blocking. Gutey brings in AJ Dillion? Yikes! Same on defense. Gutey and MLF need to be in sync - they aren’t. I think back on how Ron Wolfe and Mike Holmgren BUILT the packers. They were joined at the hip and focused on winning the conference and built their teams accordingly. All three phases. Accountability played a huge part.
I’ve been a LaFleur basher and I still feel he’s more valuable as an OC but this article does make me alter my opinion,…….slightly. It’s been noticeable to even an armchair QB like me that his assistants are really beginners, or guys willing to put up with his crap for a year or two, hoping for a chance to move on.
Would Fritz Shurmur, Bill Callahan, or Hank Farley put up with it? Uh, no.
Ty,it would be nice to see an article like this on Gutekunst. I’ve read he can be described as a person who feels the smartest guy in the room arrives as soon as he, Gutekunst, enters.
Mr. Dunne, a great series and is really enlightening to the Packers overall culture under Matt Lafleur. And yes, Lafleur has done some good, even great things under his stewardship, but ultimately they always fall short. I truly believe the "Lafleur" ship has sailed. We need a Coach that gives us the best opportunity to win. To many failures in big moments. Even when, without a doubt, we were the better team. I just think his time with Packers should be over. His team this year looks like the worst Packers team in 20 years so it should be over. Especially, if they have a losing record and miss the playoffs. He lacks the boldness confidence and self-assured presence you need to be a great leader.
And of course we’re back at “The Bay of Pigs” today, as Boomer would call it. Two teams with expectations, epic collapses, and head coaches in question. The loser won’t leave town … but it’s gonna be a pretty rough road.
Interesting read. One thing you have done, Ty, is undone the perception that MLF doesn't hold his coaches accountable, which has been something other writers were putting out there.
Yes, he is a wound-tight perfectionist, and that was known when he came from the Titans years ago. They also needed a guy who could get them from Rodgers to Love successfully; again, it worked.
I think there has been, even going back to MM, a disconnect in the players MLF needs and the ones Gute brings in...if guys don't like getting chewed out when they screw up and being held accountable, then I am sorry thats not on MLF.
Gute's buying the groceries... MLF cooking. If the guy buying those groceries isn't getting the correct ingredients, don't blame the cook when it tastes bad. Dig deeper on Gute Ty.
There’s nothing in these articles that make me think Matt LaFleur is a bad coach, much less the reason the Packers have struggled. He’s highly intelligent, detail-oreinted, chasing perfection, holds his players, staff, and himself accountable. That’s what people expect from an NFL head coach. Dunn keeps trying to draw parallels between LaFleur and McDermott, but the only thing I see is that they’ve had a few awkward moments in front of the team and Matt has reportedly really grown here. Really this article sounds like it’s the players’ messing it up, especially looking at what Dunn writes about the Bears layoffs loss. I gotta say, I see a demanding, hard-working, earnest head coach that really wants to win and is willing to endure the painful parts of growth to get there.
Matt received the worst grades from players in 8 years. The team was 9-3-1 and SB contenders when that happened. Reading the articles only reinforced of what I knew about his dealings with players. Makes me wonder why we still have coaches who should have been fired a year, two years too long. No one wants to come here to work with Matt in that type of culture. Jeff Hafley is that dude and punked Matt on the way out. Basaccia just left but did so very late in the process and probably out of spite.
I fully believe he did something to Ben Johnson or someone close to Ben Johnson because there was no reason for him to target Matt like that from the jump. 😂😂 they are coming to Lambeau next weekend to cost Matt his job and Matt better be prepared for it. After seeing how we looked against Atlanta, I don’t give us a shot against the Bears no matter who the Qb is.
I think we care too much what players think. We watched the players for Vegas try to pick their HC two years in a row and those years ended horribly.
Maybe the coaches aren’t fired when the fanbase thinks they should be because the org knows it’s a players problem and not coaching. They’re eventually fired because we have the players we have, and we gotta try something new.
Maybe it's a player problem because he doesn't develop players well. Most of the players that have left here have improved, while most of the non "star" players brought in have declined. That means something
It’s Dunne. MLF would have ripped you for the error. :).
But, all teasing aside, the open question for me is how he starts to empower his team without those old vets. Love doesn’t seem to be Rodgers, or Favre, in those contexts. Who is the next Butler, or Lang — the leader who rises to bring the fight they seem to lack. MLF can handle X’s and O’s — but can he find the right places and people to influence momentum when it’s sorely needed. That’s the question.
Good catch!
It’s a good question, but isn’t that up to the players and who the front office brings in? Mike McCarthy didn’t make TJ Lang into leader, Lang did that himself with his actions.
I’ll be interested to see if part 3 points the pen at Gutekunst. He turned this team into the youngest in the nfl for three straight years with very little vet presence and leadership. It’s been fascinating to hear Kevin Zeitler talk this week about how eager the young OLine is to learn from him
If the past foretells the future, Mr. Dunne has many parts left in this series, however the season goes :-). I’m sure the GM is going to get his share. The Packers always had a tough road for this season. It doesn’t get easier. Rebounding from 3-6 or something of the like will take a very crispy, well-polished effort of increased aggression and execution.
Agreed. LaFleur isn't perfect, but he's not a bad coach. The collapse last year was frustrating and concerning, but it was also abnormal for any NFL team. The perception by some fans that it has been a regular hallmark of his entire career is absurd.
Today against Tampa Bay, for example, he's put together a good offensive game plan. Really this is what have wanted to see from him early this year, the creativity that helped Malik Willis play so well last year (and that he hasn't gotten nearly enough credit for). He also resurrected Aaron Rodgers' career-people forget, Rodgers wasn't playing that great in McCarthy's final few years. If he's such a poor coach, Rodgers would've kept sliding downhill and LaFleur probably never makes it long enough to have Willis be a cheap backup who eventually cashed in.
It's not LaFleur's fault receivers are dropping passes today. It's not his fault the GM has neglected the offensive and defensive lines and given him sub-par cornerbacks (one a high draft pick rookie being thrown into the fire as instantly the team's best CB; the other-Nixon-who is proving he should not be an NFL starter). It's not his fault that a number of his better players are injured. Think the talent on this team is being exaggerated; this roster has some massive holes, and a number of its most talented players are injured or in the case of Love and his OL have not been protected well by the GM. Blaming all that on the coach just doesn't compute.
Adam G. : It IS LeFleur’s fault that receivers are dropping passes, It is LeFleur’s fault that the offensive line doesn’t have depth. Matt LeFleur is the head coach, responsible for the play on the field and selecting the back ups who may be on the field. To suggest otherwise absolves LeFleur of every error his team makes on the field.
It's his fault that players don't improve under him
Great articles capturing exactly what myself and a lot of other GB fans think about LaFleur. He's an excellent offensive mind, that much has always been clear. But he's unable to cope with adversity as a coach and when things start going the wrong direction, he melts down. There are precious few games, either with or without Rodgers, where the Packers have been able to right the ship midway though under LaFleur.
He may not be the sole problem, but he's not done much to convince me he has a solution.
Felt strongly after last season that LaFleur needed to go. Still feel that way. Wasn’t sure about Gutey. Now think he needs to go too. Utter disaster with oline and not enough emphasis on smarts.
Hi Tyler,
In Part Two of this LeFleur series, the Getty image of LeFleur on the sideline shows the deep haunt of fear in his eyes. LeFleur is completely afraid to fail and because he can’t control his fear, his fear of mistakes seeps into the minds of his players. He is psychologically unfit to be the head coach of Green Bay’s football team. Players put up with Lombardi’s obsession with detail because they knew he would take them where they wanted to go, and Lombardi would show his players NFL championship money, $25,000 a year by the mid-60s, which was sometimes higher than the salaries most players were making. LeFleur has won nothing, and won’t win a Super Bowl in Green Bay. LeFleur’s players know it.
I would really like to stop reminding you that Jordan Love is not one of “the best in the game” as you again said in Part One, paraphrasing on my part. He isn’t. He’s plateaued into an average quarterback, just as his high school coach warned he would become if he continued to throw off his back foot. Of the four quarterbacks in the NFC North, Love is third. If Kyle Murray continues to improve in Minnesota’s offense, Love could be last in the division by season’s end.
Other than that, Tyler, this is excellent reporting and writing. I thank you for your dogged investigation of what’s going on inside of 1265 Lombardi Ave. GoLongTD is worth every dollar, every year.
After reading the series I‘m stuck with 2 impressions:
1. incredibly illuminating and informative - and now I, who have been strongly in the fire MLF camp, am a bit less convinced about what to do. The problems are nuanced and complicated, there is no easy fix. If they had hired Harbaugh, the obvious choice, would everything be better?
2. in my opinion, the watershed moment with this organisation is and always will be the Seattle Championship Game. Something broke that day. Rodgers was never the same after that. He became much more of a Me First guy. The fans lost something that day as well. I myself expect the worst to happen more often than not. The whole aura around the Packers got destroyed. In Love‘s first season it seemed a corner was there for the taking. The W in Dallas was magic. But then the SF game….
So where does that leave everything? I think it is a culture thing and it transcends Head Coaches or QBs or GMs or Presidents. I would have loved to see a coach like Vrabel hired. But in addition, a GM with another philosophy is necessary.
E.g. I think Bob is onto something with his Wonderlic mantra.
But is Policy the person to make it happen?
Ty had to work hard for this article. It wasn't just laying down quotes. It was thinking, analysing, interpreting and studying the quotes and using them to support his points. This was like running the ball all day long and gaining 3 yards every carry. Damn good work.
I hope you will still cover his asinine stubbornness in regards to his coaches. He seems so blinded by loyalty that he refuses to fire failing coaches until it is several years too late. Look at Butkus, this line has regressed massively since he took the job, and Barry, sweet fancy moses he was in over his head, and Bisaccia. It is never ending....
Excellent insights. Character does matter.
a couple of things. 1) MLF is great at the x and o’s. The man cannot make adjustments during a game That’s a huge part of understanding the X’s and O’s. Clock management, isn’t that part of handling the X’s and O’s? Putting up with a special teams that rates near the bottom until last year when they moved up to 15th? How does poor field position equate into understanding X’s and O’s? Telling everyone from day 1, that he wants to establish the run game first without doing anything to move the needle. Being last in 3rd down conversions…..I think part of the issue is local sportswriters are afraid to call a spade a spade because if they do they’ll lose opportunities for accessing players and coaches. This market is soo small that a sports writer/announcer can’t be honest.
2). There is a disconnect between what players Gutey brings in and what MLF gets. MLF says he needs to establish the run but lo and behold every o- line MLF has had has rated poorly in run blocking. Gutey brings in AJ Dillion? Yikes! Same on defense. Gutey and MLF need to be in sync - they aren’t. I think back on how Ron Wolfe and Mike Holmgren BUILT the packers. They were joined at the hip and focused on winning the conference and built their teams accordingly. All three phases. Accountability played a huge part.
This article is why I subscribe.
I’ve been a LaFleur basher and I still feel he’s more valuable as an OC but this article does make me alter my opinion,…….slightly. It’s been noticeable to even an armchair QB like me that his assistants are really beginners, or guys willing to put up with his crap for a year or two, hoping for a chance to move on.
Would Fritz Shurmur, Bill Callahan, or Hank Farley put up with it? Uh, no.
Ty,it would be nice to see an article like this on Gutekunst. I’ve read he can be described as a person who feels the smartest guy in the room arrives as soon as he, Gutekunst, enters.
Thanks for the hard work on these stories, Ty. I appreciate getting a better understanding, as a fan, of what might be going on inside 1265.
Mr. Dunne, a great series and is really enlightening to the Packers overall culture under Matt Lafleur. And yes, Lafleur has done some good, even great things under his stewardship, but ultimately they always fall short. I truly believe the "Lafleur" ship has sailed. We need a Coach that gives us the best opportunity to win. To many failures in big moments. Even when, without a doubt, we were the better team. I just think his time with Packers should be over. His team this year looks like the worst Packers team in 20 years so it should be over. Especially, if they have a losing record and miss the playoffs. He lacks the boldness confidence and self-assured presence you need to be a great leader.
And of course we’re back at “The Bay of Pigs” today, as Boomer would call it. Two teams with expectations, epic collapses, and head coaches in question. The loser won’t leave town … but it’s gonna be a pretty rough road.