The NFL, somehow, missed on the “it” factor. We talk to the one person who believed: Dave Boller. “The lights are never too bright. One of those dudes.”
But I'll wait to coronate him until he elevates SF to the NFC championship game and/or Super Bowl. Against excellent defenses, he's prone to make mistakes at key moments, including an unexpected interception.
I apologize in advance, but this article hit a hot button for me.
<rant mode on>
Everyone missed on Purdy for the same reasons that they overvalue hothouse QBs coming out of top programs.
They focus on physical traits and the highlight reels.
They don't focus on how well and how quickly QBs process information, especially under pressure, and how accurate they are.
The NFL is different from college. The defenders are so much faster, so the windows are much tighter that the QB has to deliver the ball accurately and on time. Even if he makes the right read, if he takes too long to deliver the ball, the window closes and he might as well have thrown it into the stands. (Sometimes that would be the better throw to avoid the pick.)
If I had a dollar for every QB prospect that had all the tools and could make all the throws that busted in the NFL, I'd be a rich man.
You want to find a good NFL QB prospect? Focus on the mental and psychological stuff first, then look to see if the physical tools are good enough.
That gets you a Montana, Brady or Purdy.
But most people do it backwards and they get guys who can throw the ball but can't play the position in the NFL.
Purdy was a case of scouting malpractice. He was under pressure all the time because he played at weak school in a strong conference. You could see how he played under pressure and you knew he could deal with it. You could see the accuracy and anticipation too, because his receivers weren't good enough to get wide open consistently.
QBs coming out of top programs like Alabama, Ohio State, Georgia, etc. are like hothouse flowers. They play behind great lines. They play with great receivers. They have a great running game. Most games, they can stand behind their line, wait for a receiver to obviously come wide open, and play pitch and catch when they do.
They play defenses that can challenge them a few times a year.
You don't know how well they'll perform and process information under pressure, and you don't know how good they are at throwing into tight windows with anticipation, because they hardly ever have to do it.
Purdy had a few games a year where he wasn't playing a defense that could challenge his offense. He was playing under pressure and throwing into tight windows all the time.
But he was an inch taller than Drew Brees and doesn't have a cannon for an arm, so he almost went undrafted.
People talk about Purdy being a system QB. He is. He's an ideal fit for Shanahan's offense. He'd be an ideal fit McVay's offense, too. He'd be fine in Ben Johnson's offense.
All of those systems need a QB that processes information quickly, makes quick decisions, and delivers the the ball accurately and on time. Those offenses are complicated and the coaches wants a robo-QB - someone who will run the play the way it's drawn up.
Montana and Brady were system QBs, too.
Everyone these days loves QBs who can do things off-schedule. Off-schedule plays are great, but that's hero-ball. You have to able to execute on-schedule as well and everyone forgets that part. The off-schedule stuff should be a bonus, not the main thing.
Great feature and there is a valid argument that he is the most "valuable" player, if not the best player.
*small nit-pick* in the paragraph beginning with NFL scouts looking for traits to find the next Jackson/Mahomes/Allen, you mention he is a Big Ten product, when he is a Big Twelve product
Great story and great story Ty. Purdy will probably be the only gold jacket to be drafted last. I’d say he’s on that trajectory and I’d bet SF wins a Lombardi or more with him at the helm.
Fantastic read 👊
GREAT writing and fresh information.
Mr. Purdy a fine player, obviously....
But I'll wait to coronate him until he elevates SF to the NFC championship game and/or Super Bowl. Against excellent defenses, he's prone to make mistakes at key moments, including an unexpected interception.
I apologize in advance, but this article hit a hot button for me.
<rant mode on>
Everyone missed on Purdy for the same reasons that they overvalue hothouse QBs coming out of top programs.
They focus on physical traits and the highlight reels.
They don't focus on how well and how quickly QBs process information, especially under pressure, and how accurate they are.
The NFL is different from college. The defenders are so much faster, so the windows are much tighter that the QB has to deliver the ball accurately and on time. Even if he makes the right read, if he takes too long to deliver the ball, the window closes and he might as well have thrown it into the stands. (Sometimes that would be the better throw to avoid the pick.)
If I had a dollar for every QB prospect that had all the tools and could make all the throws that busted in the NFL, I'd be a rich man.
You want to find a good NFL QB prospect? Focus on the mental and psychological stuff first, then look to see if the physical tools are good enough.
That gets you a Montana, Brady or Purdy.
But most people do it backwards and they get guys who can throw the ball but can't play the position in the NFL.
Purdy was a case of scouting malpractice. He was under pressure all the time because he played at weak school in a strong conference. You could see how he played under pressure and you knew he could deal with it. You could see the accuracy and anticipation too, because his receivers weren't good enough to get wide open consistently.
QBs coming out of top programs like Alabama, Ohio State, Georgia, etc. are like hothouse flowers. They play behind great lines. They play with great receivers. They have a great running game. Most games, they can stand behind their line, wait for a receiver to obviously come wide open, and play pitch and catch when they do.
They play defenses that can challenge them a few times a year.
You don't know how well they'll perform and process information under pressure, and you don't know how good they are at throwing into tight windows with anticipation, because they hardly ever have to do it.
Purdy had a few games a year where he wasn't playing a defense that could challenge his offense. He was playing under pressure and throwing into tight windows all the time.
But he was an inch taller than Drew Brees and doesn't have a cannon for an arm, so he almost went undrafted.
People talk about Purdy being a system QB. He is. He's an ideal fit for Shanahan's offense. He'd be an ideal fit McVay's offense, too. He'd be fine in Ben Johnson's offense.
All of those systems need a QB that processes information quickly, makes quick decisions, and delivers the the ball accurately and on time. Those offenses are complicated and the coaches wants a robo-QB - someone who will run the play the way it's drawn up.
Montana and Brady were system QBs, too.
Everyone these days loves QBs who can do things off-schedule. Off-schedule plays are great, but that's hero-ball. You have to able to execute on-schedule as well and everyone forgets that part. The off-schedule stuff should be a bonus, not the main thing.
<rant mode off>
Great feature and there is a valid argument that he is the most "valuable" player, if not the best player.
*small nit-pick* in the paragraph beginning with NFL scouts looking for traits to find the next Jackson/Mahomes/Allen, you mention he is a Big Ten product, when he is a Big Twelve product
GREAT catch! Thank you!
Great story and great story Ty. Purdy will probably be the only gold jacket to be drafted last. I’d say he’s on that trajectory and I’d bet SF wins a Lombardi or more with him at the helm.